experiment: muon-survival-two-frames

type: init

actor: coordinator-muon-trial

role: coordinator

to: brainstorm

post_type: understanding

question: How do time dilation and length contraction give the same muon survival probability?

branch: post/muon-survival-two-frames


experiment: muon-survival-two-frames

type: submit

actor: research-brainstormer-muon-trial

from: brainstorm

note: Prospective Understanding protocol ready for fresh independent question review; receipt binds the preregistration by digest; no production result exists or was inspected.


type: review

to: brainstorm

decision: revise

note: Read-only reviewer could not bind submitted bytes because its sandbox helper failed; no scientific judgment was made; route backward for a fresh versioned resubmission and functioning independent review.


note: Versioned unchanged resubmission after infrastructure-only review failure; protocol remains byte-identical and no production result exists.


to: setup

decision: approve

note: Fresh read-only streamed-byte review found no blockers and approved the prospective Understanding protocol without calculating an outcome.


actor: experiment-engineer-muon-trial

from: setup

note: Frozen implementation, exact environment, manifests, schemas, toy tests, and immutable run contract ready for independent setup review; canonical production remains absent.


note: Independent setup review found five blocking implementation defects; route to setup for code/tests/receipt revision under unchanged frozen protocol.


note: All five setup-review blockers addressed under unchanged protocol; complete synthetic pipeline and 16 branch tests pass; canonical production remains absent.


note: Independent iteration-2 setup review found four remaining implementation blockers; route to setup under unchanged prospective protocol.


note: All iteration-2 lifecycle and integrity blockers fixed under unchanged protocol; 21 independent synthetic tests pass; production remains absent.


note: Exact verified-byte identity must survive authoritative replay; historical evidence must be consumed from hash-bound bytes; metrics write/check must enforce the full result contract.


note: Exact-byte replay/consumption, bound historical evidence, full metrics result validation, and negative-lifetime coverage complete; 25 safe tests pass; production remains absent.


note: Recompute full result/check/admission identity; bind exact graph/verifier bytes; specify retry analysis commands; refresh prospective README.


note: Full raw-to-metrics recomputation and admission identity, captured graph/verifier bytes, exact registered-retry analysis commands, and durable README status complete; 26 safe tests pass; production remains absent.


note: Fix canonical registered-analysis import/coverage and replace ambiguous run-ID substring evidence with one exact structured admitted-run marker and cross-pair rejection.


note: Canonical registered-analysis path and exact admitted-run marker contract now covered for normal/retry and cross-pair rejection; 28 bounded tests pass; production remains absent.


note: Make workflow fixtures independent of live ledger state and make result, PNG, and metrics publication staged, atomic, and restart-safe with interruption tests.


note: Stable state-independent workflow fixtures and atomic restart-safe derived publication implemented; 32 bounded tests pass in setup and archived setup_review states; production remains absent.


to: execute

note: Prospective implementation, fixtures, retry/admission, raw-to-metrics validation, and atomic publication approved; production remains unexposed.


from: execute

note: run-001 executed exactly once and sealed complete; six-file bundle passes schema, manifest, provenance, and hash checks; no analysis or scientific inspection.


to: analyze

note: run-001 is complete, hash-valid, prospectively authorized, and solely admissible; no retry or deviation; scientific outcome remains uninspected.


role: analyst

from: analyze

note: Frozen analysis, 1200x630 figure, metrics, and checks complete from admitted run-001; all six gates and 40 details pass; no rerun, deviation, verdict, or amendment.


note: Revise panel B to visibly state both frame-specific distance/time routes; preserve scientific results and rerun no production work. Repeat full analysis review via streamed evidence.


note: Presentation revision stopped before mutation: the accepted run binds the setup manifest, which binds the canonical renderer. Independent review must decide whether a versioned analysis-only provenance layer is permissible under revise or whether the graph requires amend.


decision: amend

note: Post-exposure renderer/provenance correction requires amendment; preserve admitted raw run-001, do not rerun absent separately reviewed authorization, and freeze a narrowly scoped presentation-only successor contract.


note: Presentation-only amended protocol v2 is hash-bound by the receipt; author recommends park because graph v1 cannot lawfully reuse admitted raw run-001 through its mandatory new-run execution route.


to: parked

decision: park

note: Graph v1 has no honest analysis-only post-exposure amendment path: preserve all evidence and park rather than rerun, disguise reuse, substitute roles, or invent an edge.